• EU HRC (N. Europe)€750–785/tex-works N. Europe; seller tradeable €770–780/t for January volumes; buyer indications €750–765/t and €780–785/t ex-works; Fastmarkets index €770.83/t on 12 Nov12 Nov 2026 · Fastmarkets via EUROMETAL
  • China steel exports9.854 MtOctober; Jan–Oct 95.495 Mt, −2.3% y/y10 Nov 2026 · China Customs via Mysteel / SMM
  • World crude steel142.4 MtSeptember, −0.2% y/y23 Oct 2026 · worldsteel
  • Iron ore fines 61%$90.35/dmtseaborne 61% fines, SMM; +$0.15/dmt d/d13 Nov 2026 · SMM via Hellenic Shipping News
  • Turkish HMS 1&2 (80:20)$397/tCFR, October average11 Nov 2026 · GMK Center
  • EU CBAM certificate€82.32Q3 2026 price, per certificate5 Oct 2026 · European Commission
  • US Section 232 steel10%–50%tariff, by product/country8 Oct 2026 · Congressional Research Service

BF, scrap-EAF or gas-DRI: what each route means for a European buyer in 2027

What should a European buyer put in the contract? Compare steelmaking routes, emissions boundaries, project status and a clearly assumed 2027 CBAM scenario. Cost references are historical, not 2027 quotes.

By Mara AlvestadPublished Updated 4 min read
Infographic title panel: BF, scrap-EAF or gas-DRI for European buyers in 2027; CBAM cost at €80 per tonne CO2 is €56 for BF-BOF, €7 for scrap-EAF and €44 for gas-DRI
Infographic

What should a European buyer put in the contract?

For a European buyer negotiating 2027 steel supply, a furnace label is not a delivery or carbon guarantee. Put the grade, delivery milestone, measured emissions and substitute-supply rights in the contract. The carbon side now matters more: the benchmark EU carbon allowance was €90.16/t on 5 November 2026 (Dec-26 contract; €89.19 settlement on 30 October), so we show CBAM import costs at €60, €80 and €100/tCO₂.

Advertise

Reach steel buyers and importers worldwide

Put your brand in front of the people who buy and trade steel.

Advertise with Loharo

We no longer quote dollar cost bands. Published route costs still rest on pre-2022 inputs, so we give relative cost only: Columbia’s 2024 review puts BF-BOF lowest on global average, scrap-EAF close behind and gas-DRI above both, with wide regional swings. The IEA’s 2025 review puts early fully hydrogen-based plants 50–140% above BF-BOF. Gas-DRI and hydrogen-DRI are not the same offer.

Loharo comparison of BF-BOF, scrap-EAF and gas-DRI-EAF for European buyers in 2027. EU carbon price €90.16 per tonne CO2 (Dec-26 EUA, 5 November 2026). Scenario 2027 CBAM import cost per tonne of steel at €60, €80 and €100 per tonne CO2: BF-BOF €42, €56, €70; scrap-EAF €5, €7, €9; gas-DRI-EAF €33, €44, €55, from assumed direct emissions E of 2.00, 0.15 and 1.00 and illustrative benchmarks B of 1.364, 0.066 and 0.475 at a 95% factor. Worldsteel global route means 2022 to 2024, a different boundary from CBAM: 2.33 to 2.34, 0.67 to 0.69 and 1.36 to 1.47 tonnes CO2 per tonne. Relative cost: BF-BOF lowest on global average, scrap-EAF close to it, gas-DRI above it; early hydrogen-DRI plants 50 to 140% above BF-BOF. Examples: ArcelorMittal Dunkirk EAF targeted for 2029; Arvedi Cremona EAFs operating; SSAB Oxelösund EAF start planned Q2 2027; thyssenkrupp Duisburg DRI to start on gas; Stegra Boden needs extra capital.
Loharo analysis. CO₂: worldsteel 2022–24 (different boundary from CBAM); CBAM: EC guidance 4 and 5d; carbon price: Dec-26 EUA, 5 Nov 2026; relative cost: Columbia CKI 2024, IEA 2025. Open the graphic for full size.
Worldsteel CO₂ means use a different boundary from CBAM; E inputs are Loharo assumptions and B values the Commission guide’s illustrative benchmarks, not a declaration
Route2022 → 2023 → 2024 CO₂, t/t (worldsteel)Scenario E / B, t/t2027 CBAM, €/t at €60 / €80 / €100
BF–BOF2.33 → 2.33 → 2.342.00 / 1.36442.25 / 56.34 / 70.42
Scrap–EAF0.67 → 0.69 → 0.690.15 / 0.0665.24 / 6.98 / 8.73
Gas-DRI–EAF1.36 → 1.43 → 1.471.00 / 0.47532.93 / 43.90 / 54.88

Keep the boundaries separate

The history uses worldsteel’s original CO₂ series, not its expanded greenhouse-gas indicator. These global annual means include electricity and other boundaries beyond CBAM direct emissions; the DRI series also mixes gas and coal-based reduction. They are neither mill-level ranges nor promises for hydrogen steel.

Analysis — import-cost scenario: assume €60, €80 or €100/tCO₂ (the market was €90.16 on 5 November), direct embedded emissions E of 2.00/0.15/1.00 t/t and full-chain B of 1.364/0.066/0.475 for BF/scrap/DRI. Using the guide’s 95% 2027 factor and illustrative Table 2-3 benchmarks, correction factor 1 and no overseas carbon-price credit: cost = price × max(E − 0.95B, 0). BF working at €80: (2.00 − 0.95 × 1.364) × €80 = €56.34/t; at €100 it is €70.42/t. The CBAM certificate price will follow EU auction prices, so update the scenario with the market.

The steel guidance uses embedded direct emissions, not the worldsteel averages. An actual declaration needs the applicable CN code, origin, production year, verified inputs or prescribed defaults, precursors and carbon-price evidence; the total free-allocation adjustment cannot simply be borrowed from this panel. EU-made steel faces ETS; CBAM concerns covered imports.

Availability and the buying decision

Dunkirk remains a BF site; ArcelorMittal targets its new EAF for 2029. Arvedi Cremona already operates EAF flat-steel lines. SSAB’s 28 October report targets Q2 2027 for the Oxelösund EAF; thyssenkrupp’s Duisburg DRI plant will start on natural gas; Stegra’s 30 September update says Boden needs more completion funding. A project target is not confirmed saleable output.

Analysis — buyer: contract for an emissions limit and dated grade approval. Mill: power, feedstock and ramp-up determine what can be promised. Trader/service centre: retain heat-level evidence and agree an approved substitute if the nominated route slips. No route supplies a universal lead time in weeks.

What would change this view: verified supplier emissions, binding delivery terms or a revised commissioning date. Next action: review these conditions before 1 January 2027 and at every delivery promise; use current supplier offers, not route averages, to negotiate price. See also why hydrogen-ready can mean gas first.

Verification status: Verified

Route data, carbon price and company statements were checked against the sources listed on 4 November 2026; links, carbon price and the Infographic tag re-checked on 5 November 2026. The CBAM figures are an explicitly assumed scenario, not a supplier default or a customs declaration; relative cost is a global-average ranking, not a European offer.

Ask the Analyst

“What could CBAM add to Indian HRC delivered to Rotterdam in 2027?”: landed cost with duty, quota and CBAM in one answer.Ask the Analyst

Sources

Primary sources

Last fact-check: 5 November 2026.

Facts, analysis and uncertainty are labelled in line with our editorial standards. Report an error – corrections are dated and noted on the article. Information and analysis only, not investment advice.